Vulpes Libris

A collective of bibliophiles talking about books. Book Fox (vulpes libris): small bibliovorous mammal of overactive imagination and uncommonly large bookshop expenses. Habitat: anywhere the rustle of pages can be heard.

Chávez: un hombre que anda por ahí / A man who walks around

800px-Operemm-2

Photo by the Presidency of the Nation of Argentina, via Wikimedia Commons

I was born on the 28th of July, 1954. My mother was expecting to have a girl, and as a good Christian and Catholic, she called her first boy Adán [Adam], and I was supposed to be Eva, in order to make Paradise. So I was the second child and, as I couldn’t be Eva, they gave me my father’s name; and my second name, Rafael, comes from my maternal grandfather, Rafael Infante. It was my mother who finally named me—it’s always like that, in the end.

– p. 74, Family Memories. All translations are my own.

The death of Hugo Rafael Chávez Frías, and his promotion in death to supreme leader and commander emeritus of the Bolivarian revolution, has left what I can only describe as a great big hole in world politics. His is a noticeable absence, because—until ill health started to draw him away—he was so very much there: a vivid, mutable, outspoken presence. I feel it myself, although I do not live in Venezuela and have no right to a stake in its politics. But Chávez, like his friend and comrade Lula (who called him, in rather a wonderful turn of phrase, “eighty percent heart and twenty percent brain“), was an intrinsic part of my cultural and political world. Every time I opened up BBC Mundo I would ask myself: what has that man done now? And there would usually be something, whether hopeful, or infuriating, or satisfying, or contrary, or commonsensical, or disturbing. And it would always matter.

It might seem strange, to mark the passing of a man who was nothing if not full of surprises by reviewing a book published in 2005. But there is plenty of material out there for any reader who wants a biographical sketch (incidentally, this photo narrative on MSN UK is surprisingly good, and compares favourably to the more histrionic stuff filling the broadsheets); and if what you’re after is a response to the man’s death, well, take your pick. There’s a wealth of it out there from every political angle, from Tariq Ali and Oscar Guardiola-Rivera, Lula and Owen Jones, to Michael White, Rory Carroll, Daniel Hannan, and this characteristic Economist editorial. And that’s just the UK press (well, mostly). What Aleida Guevara’s book brings to the party, despite its age, is a window into Chávez’s personality, his self-representation in a comparatively relaxed setting. It is the equivalent of a snapshot taken by a friend.

The title—Chávez: un hombre que anda por ahí—literally means “a man who walks around,” although the English translation is entitled Chávez, Venezuela and the New Latin America. That doesn’t quite communicate the nature of the book or its narrative, which is definitely more of a wander than the English title might suggest. The book incorporates two interviews conducted by Guevara in Caracas in 2004: the first under the self-explanatory title of Venezuela Today, the second—Reflections—incorporating Chávez’s thoughts about his family, Fidel Castro, the war in Iraq, ALBA, and the referendum of August 2004. It also includes a transcript of Guevara’s appearance on Chávez’s weekly TV show, Aló Presidente, and an interview with then Defence Minister Jorge García Carneiro about the failed coup of 2002, which removed Chávez from office for two days, and about the role of the military in Venezuelan political life. Guevara’s contributions to the dialogue are largely edited out, but she evidently does not ask her subject sticky questions—you’d want the BBC Hardtalk interview for that—nor try to direct the flow of his responses, which seem to be transcribed pretty much directly, with the minimum of editorial tidying-up. This means that the reader gets a real taste of Chávez’s conversational style, as here, when he describes his encounter with a drunk following his famous first visit to Cuba in 1994 (I’ve deliberately kept the translation as close as I can):

Remember that our people had been bombarded with Fidel and Chávez, the embrace and I don’t know what else. I get out of the car, and a drunk’s coming up the middle of the road with a bottle in his hand, zig-zagging, but drunk, knee-walking drunk as we say here, and I go right past him, close as this—I was going to turn round and cross the street—but he was walking straight towards me with his bottle—well, he wasn’t walking straight at all—and then he says, “You look like Chávez,” he was a young man, and I say “I am Chávez, how are you?” and I shake his hand, he babbles two or three things and walks on, and I walk on too, but in the other direction, and suddenly I hear from behind me: “Chávez!” And I turn round, I’ll never forget the look on his face. “Chávez, viva Fidel!” (pp 97-98)

What these interviews offer is a chance to know a little more of the things that made up the man: his preoccupations and convictions, his attachments, his references, and the military culture and education that were fundamental not only to his early political experience and radicalisation, but to his mature leadership. This is no substitute for informed, sustained reading. But it is something that even the best reporting cannot provide. To anyone who wants to understand Chávez as he was, with all the complexity that entails, it is invaluable.

Ocean Sur (Spanish), 150 pp., ISBN: 978-1920888220 / Ocean Press (English), 143 pp., ISBN: 978-1920888008

4 comments on “Chávez: un hombre que anda por ahí / A man who walks around

  1. Melrose
    March 11, 2013

    This looks like an excellent book to get to know Chavez, the man, as well as Chavez, the politician. And what I’ve learned from watching the whole of his funeral ceremony, and the totally biased way in which it was represented on UK media, is that most of us probably aren’t aware of who the man actually is, or what his political beliefs actually are, including me. This book sounds a very good way to start the job of discovery.

    As in the reporting of his funeral, the bits deliberately left out over the years in our media’s portrayal of Chavez, I think, will be far more revealing about Chavez’ character, than the bits left in. And I think, in “Chavez: A Man Who Walks Around”, we may well find a lot of the “bits we never knew about”.

    I very rarely heard, in our media, of Jesse Jackson’s personal comments, during his sermon at the ceremony, about Hugo Chavez himself, i.e., “Hugo fed the hungry. He lifted the poor. He raised their hopes. He helped them realize their dreams. And, so, today we do mourn, because we’ve lost a lot. But we have a lot left – a stable government, an orderly transition.”

    Do these personal comments not deserve to be heard? Might they not quite fit in with our two-dimensional, media drawn, perception of Chavez? Shouldn’t we be told exactly what Heads of States took time out of very busy schedules to pay respects to Venezuela’s leader, rather than the media just harking on about three countries that suit their media-portrayed Chavez image. It was never mentioned that part of the small delegation from the US (despite Chavez’ anti-US rhetoric, as the media put it) were friends with Chavez through the programme for the provision of cheap Venezuelan oil for people in poverty in New York.

    Unfortunately, the media does an excellent job in presenting a ready-packaged view for lots of people, unwilling and/or too lazy to investigate for themselves whether the positive or negative image they are fed about a person is in fact accurate. Books like “Chavez: A Man Who Walks Around” may not present a totally unbiased image themselves, but help us in our search to find the “real” person behind the image, and make our own minds up.

  2. Jackie
    March 11, 2013

    I agree with Melrose. Mr. Chavez’s reputation was even worse here in the US than in Europe and so I was surprised when a reporter I admired(Eugene Robinson of the Washington Post) talked about all he had done for the poor of his country. That was impressive and so far from the monster he is made out to be in the US media. I was left wanting to know more about Mr. Chavez and this book sounds like a good place to start.

  3. harkin
    March 12, 2013

    He did away with freedom of the press, his political enemies were either forbidden from getting state work and/or benefits and those were the lucky ones. Others he imprisoned or had murdered. He used oil money to fund neverending propaganda programs. Any stations that didn’t run his shillmongers were punished.The murder rate quadrupled, the currency is way down, he and his family stole upwards of $1 billion and another $100 billion went to helping armed gangs control the areas with terror. He also helped a bankrupt totalitariam regime in Cuba continue to stifle freedoms. Some leader.

    But because some useful idiots on the left think what he did was OK as long as more people served the state and the greatest engine for human freedom (free market economy) was vilified, you have articles like these.

  4. Melrose
    March 12, 2013

    Harkin’s post provides, I feel, an EXCELLENT example of what I mentioned in my earlier post – the media portrayal of Chavez, especially in the more florid of the right wing press. With a similarly flavoured comment about Cuba flung in for good measure to underline this bias.

    It seems to me also that the item under discussion is simply a literary review of a book about the background to a man, who happens to be Chavez, and not about a political system, and seems to be sticking very much to the brief it has been set.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Archive

Editorial Policy

The views expressed in the articles and reviews on Vulpes Libris are those of the authors, and not of Vulpes Libris itself.

Quoting from Vulpes Libris

You are very welcome to quote up to 100 words from any article posted on Vulpes Libris - as long as you quote accurately, give us due credit and link back to the original post. If you would like to quote MORE than 100 words, please ask us first via the email address in the Contact details.

Acknowledgment

  • (The header image is from Aesop's Fables, illustrated by Francis Barlow (1666), and appears courtesy of the Digital and Multimedia Center at the Michigan State University Libraries.)
  • Follow

    Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

    Join 809 other followers

    %d bloggers like this: